Judicial Appointment Decline: Justice Musarrat Hilali Declines Federal Constitutional Court Appointment

Health Concerns Prompt Decision to Step Back

Supreme Court judge Justice Musarrat Hilali has formally turned down her proposed appointment to Pakistan’s newly formed Federal Constitutional Court (FCC). Reports indicate the respected jurist cited health considerations as the primary reason for her decision. This development follows the recent delisting of her bench after she experienced a sudden medical episode. Sources close to the matter reveal Justice Hilali suffered from elevated blood pressure just prior to a court session, leading physicians to recommend immediate rest and recuperation.

Medical History Influences Career Decision

The judge’s decision comes against the backdrop of previous heart-related health challenges, though medical professionals have confirmed her condition remains stable. Justice Hilali’s withdrawal represents a significant moment in Pakistan’s judicial landscape, occurring shortly after the landmark 27th Constitutional Amendment established the FCC as a new pillar of the country’s legal framework. The amendment created a specialized court to handle constitutional matters exclusively, with Justice Aminuddin Khan appointed as its inaugural Chief Justice.

Implications for Pakistan’s Judicial Structure

Justice Hilali’s decision not to join the FCC highlights the physical demands of high judicial office and the importance of health considerations in maintaining an effective judiciary. Her choice follows a distinguished career marked by significant contributions to Pakistan’s legal system. The establishment of the FCC represents a major restructuring of constitutional jurisdiction in Pakistan, designed to streamline the handling of fundamental legal questions while reducing the burden on the Supreme Court’s regular roster.